Roofing Blog

The Advantages and Disadvantages of Metal Roofing, Revealed

Investing in metal roofing is not only one of the most important renovations for your home’s integrity, but it can also boost its value significantly. 

According to reports, replacing your roof can trigger an average ROI of 107%. What’s more, 33% of real estate agents say that a roof replacement can help close home sales. 

Whether you’re choosing a roof for a new home or replacing an existing roof, one of the most important decisions you’ll need to make is what roofing material to use. 

Metal roofing is becoming a popular choice thanks to its many advantages. However, there are a few disadvantages you should also keep in mind. 

Wondering if a metal roof is the best choice for you? Keep reading to learn more about the pros and cons. 

Advantages of Metal Roofing

Metal roofing is fast becoming a favorite roof material in North America. Market data shows that it accounts for 13% of residential re-roofing in the US, making it the second most used material. 

Here are some of the reasons why metal roofing is such a sought-after choice for homeowners. 

Metal Is One of the Most Long-Lasting Roof Materials

One of the big advantages of metal roofing is its longevity. If properly installed, it can last between 50-75 years on average. This is more than double that of asphalt shingles, which typically last between 15-30 years. If not cared for, asphalt shingle roof lifespans can drop to 12-15 years.

Besides being having a longer lifespan than most other types of roofing materials, metal roofing is also incredibly durable. It is highly resistant to wind damage, and can also stand up well to impact. 

The superior strength of metal roofing is one of the big factors driving its demand, especially in areas like Florida and Texas where extreme weather events are on the rise. 

Metal Roofs Are Fireproof

Besides being resistant to storms and high winds, metal roofs are also fireproof. So much so that certain insurance carriers offer lower premiums to homeowners who have metal roofs. 

This makes it one of the best choices in areas that experience wildfires. 

Contrary to popular belief, they also don’t attract lightning. 

It’s Easier for Snow to Slide off Metal Roofing

One of the lesser-known advantages is it presents less resistance to snow. Because metal roofs are smoother than most other roof types, it’s easier for snow to slide off them. 

This is ideal if you live in an area that receives heavy snowfall. The less snow that can build up on your roof, the less likelihood there is of ice dams developing. Too much snow on your roof can damage your guttering system, and even cause your roof to collapse in places. 

Metal Roofs Reflect Heat

Another benefit is it reflects heat. One study analyzing the efficiency found that heat flow dropped by 45% with a metal roof, and cooling costs were reduced by 25%. 

The exact amount that it will drop your cooling costs will depend on the type of installation. 

Metal Roofing Is Recyclable

A final benefit is that it’s 100% recyclable. Reports from NAHB show that up to composite roofing materials make up 5% of landfill waste. This equates to 1.36 billion pounds of waste going into landfills each year from composite roofing alone. 

Metal, on the other hand, is a highly recyclable material. Not only is it recyclable, but there’s a good chance that the metal roofing you install already compromises some recycled metal. 

This makes it one of the most sustainable roofing options available. 

Disadvantages of Metal Roofing

new roof installation is a big outlay, so it’s important to be aware of both the pros and the cons. Overall, the benefits of a metal roof outweigh the cons, but there are still a few drawbacks you might want to keep in mind. 

Here are the main disadvantages to consider before pressing go on your new roof installation. 

Metal Roofing Is Louder in Rain or Hail

They tend to be noisier than other roofing types when it’s raining or during a hail storm. However, modern insulation techniques methods can help dampen the sound of falling rain and hail. 

Also, some people enjoy the sound of rain on a metal roof, so this isn’t necessarily a con for every homeowner.

Metal Roofing Is More Slippery

Another disadvantage is metal roofs are more slippery than most other types of roofing. While this is an advantage when it comes to snow season, it’s not advantageous for climbing around on your roof.

Climbing onto a metal roof while it’s damp is not a good idea; even dry metal roofs can be slippery underfoot. 

Metal Roofing Is More Expensive

The primary con is cost. Exact costs vary, but on average you can expect to pay roughly double for a metal roofing installation than for an asphalt shingle roof installation. 

However, it does has a far longer lifespan than asphalt shingles. If you take this into account, metal roofs aren’t necessarily more “expensive”, but they do come with a higher upfront cost. 

It Not Properly Installed Metal Roofing Can Fail at the Seams

Another potential con is it can fail at the seams if not properly installed. 

However, if you choose an experienced installer who knows what they are doing, this shouldn’t be an issue. Therefore, make sure you vet your installer thoroughly and only opt for one that has a reputation for professionalism.

Are You Looking For a Professional Metal Roofing Installer You Can Trust?

If you can afford the upfront cost, installing metal roofing is a savvy move. Not only is it long-lasting and durable, but it is also recyclable, fireproof, and heat reflective. 

The key to ensuring a long life on your metal roof is to go with a roofing installer who is experienced and provides a professional service. 

Rising Star Roofing is a family-owned business and a member of the National Roofing Contractors Association (NRCA). We take pride in exceeding the expectations of our clients. 

Contact us today for a free estimate.